The 5 Second Rule: Critiquing the Best Websites of 2009

If a customer to your touchdown web page can’t determine what you’re providing throughout the first 5 seconds, you’ve in all probability misplaced them. There’s merely an excessive amount of to do on-line today.

Some folks say 8 seconds, some say that after 3 seconds the choice has been made. So for the sake of argument we’re going to stay within the center and discover The 5 Second Rule because it applies touchdown pages.

Visiting the Finest Web sites of 2009 for five Seconds

For this collection of posts we’re going to be taking a stroll by Time Magazines “50 Best Sites of 2009”.

This week we’re critiquing the next websites:

1. Flickr
2. California Shoreline
3. Scrumptious
4. Metafilter
5. Popurls
6. Twitter
7. Skype
8. Boing Boing
9. Tutorial Earth
10. Open Desk

Success Standards

For every website we’ll apply the 5 second rule and rating it in response to 5 frequent standards for profitable touchdown pages:

1. What’s it about?: How apparent is the core model message?
2. Do I care?: Am I ? Does it communicate to me?
3. Is it reliable?: Does the design make me really feel comfy? Do they seem skilled?
4. How do I take part?: What am I purported to do first? Is the first name to motion introduced in a transparent method?
5. Is it newsworthy?: Given right this moment’s social net financial system, how possible am I to need to share my expertise? Is that this facilitated in any means?

These are deliberately fairly generic first rules as we’re overlaying a number of various kinds of website, and are just one kind of touchdown web page – the homepage. It’s our perception that one of the best performing touchdown pages have a single aim and are designed for and targeted on particular person campaigns, versus the homepage which tries to be the whole lot to everybody.

However first…

What’s the 5 Second Rule?

It depends upon who you ask…

The 5 Second Rule Utilized to Internet Usability and Touchdown Web page Design

In net circles it’s a sort of usability check used to evaluate the affect and readability of an internet web page. You present a check topic an internet web page for five seconds, then disguise it and ask them what the aim of the web page was. It’s an efficient option to gauge the main target of your touchdown pages.

It’s additionally the size of time society permits you to scramble to reclaim meals you dropped on the ground.

The 5 Second Rule In line with City Dictionary

The rule by which one determines whether or not or not meals is secure after falling onto the ground. That’s, if you’ll be able to retrieve stated merchandise inside 5 seconds, it’s not soiled and is fit for human consumption.

* Word: in fraternity homes, this rule is the 1.5 second rule. Rule is invalid within the restroom.

Particular person 1: Oh no, my hen wing fell on the ground!
Particular person 2: 5 … 4 … 3 … 2 …
Particular person 1: Acquired it!
Particular person 2: 5-second rule. It’s yours, dude.

The 5 Second Rule on YouTube

---

The Finest Web sites of 2009 : 1-10

You’ll discover a number of massive and standard websites within the checklist as we progress, however for this check we’re going to try to be as model unaware as potential, and concentrate on our standards and what we see throughout these vital first 5 seconds. They seem within the order listed by Time Journal – which doesn’t seem like in any particular order. Nonetheless, on the finish of this 5-part collection we’ll have the ability to rank them in response to their landing-page-scorecard-awesomeness-factor, in any other case know within the biz as LPSAF (true story).

Web site 1 – Flickr

What’s it about?	Flickr do a fantastic job right here. Utilizing an enormous, daring and concise definition of their core goal – entrance and middle.	10
Do I care?	If I’m like many of the fashionable world and personal a digital camera of some type and have associates then sure. They’re very related.	8
Is it reliable?	The design is clear {and professional} which makes me consider they’re an excellent firm. In addition they have a Yahoo Id reference beneath the be part of button which provides them a number of inherent belief factors by affiliation.With over 3 million gadgets on their website, I do know that others are taking part which boosts my perception that they are often trusted.	10
How do I take part	Loads of easy actions are introduced that reply my preliminary questions. Can I have a look at different pictures now with out an account? Sure. Is there a distinguished sign-up button? Sure. Are the core options introduced in a easy means? Sure. Is there a easy means for me to search out out extra earlier than I commit? Sure (the guided tour).	10
Is it newsworthy?	Photograph websites are usually not unusual, and I’m unsure proper off the bat what makes this particular (whether it is). So I might say that the neighborhood side of it (Share Your Images) will inherently imply that I’ll find yourself sharing it with my associates. However I may not instantly suppose to inform somebody concerning the website.	8

Web site 2 – California Shoreline

What’s it about?	That is very apparent from the massive title on the prime of the web page. A easy idea communicated successfully.	10
Do I care?	As a photographer myself, I’ve an computerized stage of curiosity in what it’s about and the way they did it. However the picture introduced on the homepage is random and as such the chances are it gained’t all the time be anyting spectacular. So whereas attention-grabbing, it’s not significantly thrilling. The design can be very mid-90s and as such is a little bit of a flip off.	6
Is it reliable?	They’ve a .org area extension and over 7 million guests (albeit proven with an archaic hit counter), so sure, it feels reliable. They’re additionally not presenting any limitations to entry so I don’t should be involved about privateness.	10
How do I take part	I’m not 100% certain what they’re saying I ought to do first. Ought to I be looking for a location to view it? The navigation on the left could be very small and has 1,000,000 issues in it, so I don’t have a transparent path to one of the best or most related content material on the location.	7
Is it newsworthy?	When you’ve got some form of connection to California (associates, household, a earlier trip and so forth), then sure it could possibly be the case that you simply’d need to discover a location you’re acquainted with and see if it’s on there. HOwever, I may also try this with Google Maps & Google Earth, so the viral potential is proscribed.	7

Web site 3 – Scrumptious

What’s it about?	They make it apparent what the aim of the location is. Off the bat I wouldn’t get why the bookmarks are social, however nonetheless I understand it’s a bookmarking website. Nonetheless it’s not clear the place the bookmarks are saved. Are they totally different from those in my browser? (I do know they’re, however for the uninitiated, it’s not made clear). The be taught extra hyperlink takes you to a web page that explains it properly, however the hyperlink was very small.	8
Do I care?	Realizing that it shops the bookmarks on-line, I can image a use of the service. Apart from that although, it simply appears to be like like one other website with a bunch of web site or information listings.	7
Is it reliable?	It’s the largest within the universe! And has a contemporary net 2.0 design. It’s additionally free to enroll and the shape isn’t too lengthy. So sure, I belief them.	9
How do I take part	There’s a pretty robust name to go looking the bookmarks, and the bookmarks or websites on the homepage are organized by reputation or newness. Be part of and sign-up buttons are apparent. Nonetheless the 5 slide header part feels wasted on poor communication.	8
Is it newsworthy?	Sure, I haven’t seen one other website like this earlier than. However I’m actually not all that enthusiastic about it as my use of the service isn’t utterly apparent.	7

Web site 4 – Metafilter

What’s it about?	I’ve no actual clue what it’s about. Neighborhood weblog is the one descriptive aspect on the web page. Which neighborhood? I’d prefer to see a clearer model worth message. After studying the about part it’s very apparent what it’s about. If they’d put only one succinct assertion on the homepage I might be extra inclined to stay round.	6
Do I care?	There may be a lot textual content on the web page that it’s laborious to discover a cause to hold round, so no, probably not.	4
Is it reliable?	The design is poor, and I don’t get a way of a big or fashionable firm being behind it so I’m probably not feeling like I’m in a spot of explicit worth or professionalism.	5
How do I take part	No actual sense of what I ought to do first. There’s a tiny be part of hyperlink, however I’ve been given no cause or clarification of why to hitch. If there have been a bigger search field I’d use that straight away to see if the content material is nice and related to me).	5
Is it newsworthy?	I wouldn’t inform anybody about this website from my preliminary impressions. If they’d a stronger worth proposition and an apparent mechanism for sharing with somebody it might get a better rating.	2

Web site 5 – popurls

What’s it about?	Instantly I can see that that is an aggregation of content material from standard social media websites.	10
Do I care?	Very a lot so. Scrolling down the web page, I see that it has content material from in all places, and I can think about it being a fantastic time-saving website to frequent or probably use as my browser homepage.	10
Is it reliable?	As all it’s doing is grabbing content material from different websites, I’ve no cause to not belief them. And because the websites referenced are all acquainted I’ve an inherent belief by affiliation. I gained’t be paying for a service so I’m assured that it’s a secure place to be.	9
How do I take part	I can browse, search or customise the content material to make it extra helpful. That’s clear straight away, and quite simple to understand.	9
Is it newsworthy?	Sure. I might be an advocate of this website and would let others find out about it. In addition they have a quite simple and fast technique of sharing the content material with associates (I noticed this when hovering over a hyperlink).	10

Web site 6 – Twitter

What’s it about?	They trace at what the location is about, and the homepage could be very easy. The search lets me get into seeing what individuals are saying straight away, however that makes me really feel just like the search is the core operate fairly than it’s use as private comunication device.	7
Do I care?	I’m not offered by any actual worth proposition at this level. However the enroll kind could be very brief so I’d in all probability give it a go. Luckily for Twitter, their model is so pervasive that I’m nearly peer-pressured into caring.	8
Is it reliable?	The design is straightforward and clear, and there’s the unavoidable model attain that Twitter has obtained, so no matter whether or not or not I do know what it’s for, I’ve heard folks speaking about it, so I’m going to base my belief on phrase of mouth which could be very robust.	10
How do I take part	The search field is massive and apparent and the one different essential issues to do is enroll, so my choices are clear. I might nonetheless prefer to be given some indication of the truth that my cause for being right here is for micro-blogging.	9
Is it newsworthy?	Apparently so – as everybody else is speaking about it.	10

Web site 7 – Skype

What’s it about?	Clearly about low cost telephone calls, but it surely doesn’t appear to need to inform me that it’s executed by a pc, so it might simply be any telecom or telephone card firm. There are hints such because the “Mac OS X Model”, but it surely’s not clearly said in a succinct method.	7
Do I care?	I positively care as a result of it appears to be wonderful worth, and long-distance telephone calls are a actuality for most individuals. So I’ll a minimum of click on by to the “discover out extra” web page which exhibits me the unbelievable costs.	9
Is it reliable?	The completely happy cloud design, brilliant colours, net 2.0 sensibilities and professional design put me in an excellent temper instantly. I’m beginning to discover a typical theme with designs that characteristic sky blue and white fluffy clouds. It’s a very gentle and fuzzy feeling. One thing to be careful for.	9
How do I take part	Clear navigation and a single essential CTA to search out out extra is all I really want to know. I’m assured that if I click on the “discover Out Extra” button my questions will likely be answered.	10
Is it newsworthy?	Given the costs and the flexibility to name household in international nations for subsequent to nothing, I might say this has huge sharing and viral potential. I might interact my household to enroll straight away.	10

Web site 8 – Boing Boing

What’s it about?	My solely actual clue is the tagline – “A Listing of Great Issues”. Apart kind that it appears to be like and appears like a private weblog. From the navigation I can see it’s about devices and video and one thing else I can’t actually determine (as a result of illegible font).	6
Do I care?	My curiosity could be extremely dictated by the luck inherent within the first story having a headline of curiosity. Solely 2 headlines seem above the fold on my very massive monitor so the probabilities of my curiosity being tweaked is pretty restricted.	6
Is it reliable?	I don’t really feel significantly seduced by the design, and it simply appears to be like like a private weblog. As such it’s not one thing I’m going to be signing up for, making belief much less of a problem.	6
How do I take part	I can enroll – however I don’t perceive why I might need to – there’s no indication of what I get for an account on the sign-up web page. Apart from that, all I might do is scroll down the web page and maybe navigate to a distinct part. This lack of course is as a result of unclear goal of the location.	6
Is it newsworthy?	Probably. Once more it comes again to the highest story of the second. And actually which will make the story newsworthy, however the website itself doesn’t do something significantly authentic from a primary look.	5

Web site 9 – Tutorial Earth

What’s it about?	Aah, again to readability. The aim of the location could be very clear inside a second of arrival.	10
Do I care?	Even when I’m not in an educational house proper now, there’s a massive attraction based mostly on the truth that it’s providing full video programs from trusted sources.	10
Is it reliable?	The affiliation with main universities makes it really feel very reliable. No considerations in that division. The Time.com brand on the backside confirms it’s relevance and respect.	10
How do I take part	By clicking on one of many 3 featured movies, I used to be watching a 2hr lecture inside seconds. No limitations to entry. Very spectacular. A distinguished search field lets me know that I can search for movies of extra focused curiosity.	10
Is it newsworthy?	Very a lot so. Everybody is aware of somebody who’s presently studying, finding out or keen on nice video content material. I might share this and evangelize their service with confidence that it might mirror positively on me in consequence.	10

Web site 10 – Open Desk

What’s it about?	It appears pretty clear that it’s about restaurant reservations, however the design instantly smacks of a site squatter that simply farms out hyperlinks, so I’m not assured straight away if that’s the core goal of the location.	7
Do I care?	As a heavy web person, I’m within the potential to guide tables on-line, nonetheless, my insecurity within the website makes me cautious. It’s price noting although, {that a} typical use of this website might happen with a small group (or couple) at a pc, the place a number of units of eyes might maintain the eye on the web page longer.	6
Is it reliable?	In no way. I’m pretty assured that I’d make the belief that it’s a parked area and simply transfer on with out actually utilizing the service.	2
How do I take part	The first CTAs are buried within the design and don’t stand out to make me know instantly the place I ought to start. I want to see an enormous daring button stating that I can guide a desk at considered one of hundreds of eating places proper now. The data is there when you hunt, but it surely’s too textual content based mostly to be noticeable at a look. A big Google’esque search field with clever auto-complete would even be appreciated in order that I can simply start typing the title or location of my favourite restaurant or metropolis and begin seeing outcomes.	4
Is it newsworthy?	If I had been satisfied to take part in a less complicated method it could very properly be one thing I’d share. However given the sensation that I wouldn’t have hung round I’m going to should go straight down the center on this one.	5

---

Websites 1-10 Conclusions

There have been just a few surprises right here. Massive websites which have huge followings are breaking some elementary guidelines (and are in all probability in a position to get away with it). Nonetheless, what this exhibits is that even one of the best websites have room to enhance their focus of their messaging in order that they don’t lose useful clients in these very important few first seconds. We will additionally see that sure websites corresponding to OpenTable.com are actually doing themselves a disservice.

Tutorial Earth was the runaway chief when it comes to first impressions. You might be taught so much about communication and eradicating limitations to entry from their method.

---

And Lastly… 5 Causes Why Your Homepage Gained’t Make a Good Touchdown Web page

1. Touchdown pages ought to have a single targeted message. Homepages are likely to have all issues for all folks, appearing like a portal to website exploration.
2. A scarcity of connection to the upstream advert. Until you’ve got some very fancy back-end logic in place, it’s unlikely you’ll have the ability to make sure the messaging from a banner or paid textual content advert will likely be repeated on the homepage (particularly when you find yourself working a number of campaigns). This may make you look lazy and reduces momentum.
3. Elevated value for PPC. Google will usually cost you much less for a touchdown web page that very carefully mirrors the content material of an AdWords advert. A homepage is means too basic for tight coupling along with your advert content material.
4. Dropping your site visitors to John Doe upstairs. In a big multi-channel group, totally different enterprise models will likely be liable for separate areas of the location. Whereas it’s nice if a buyer wanders off and converts someplace on the location, I’m but to satisfy a marketer that didn’t need to preserve their site visitors inside their very own private sphere of affect.
5. Monitoring points. A single one-page touchdown web page is straightforward to measure when it comes to bounce charge and conversion charge. If you throw a homepage into the combo, your clients might wander aimlessly and nonetheless finally find yourself within the desired place. In case your analytics are good you’ll be high quality, however the further complexity makes it extra, properly, advanced…

---

In Half 2…

Verify again once more subsequent week for our critique of websites 11-20, together with Google, Netflix, Amazon and YouTube.

— Oli Gardner

---

What Subsequent?

Follow Unbounce on Twitter | Obtain the Free “101 Landing Page Optimization Tips” White Paper